Trailways to Treasures
A Brief History of Routes 5 & 20
 
 
 
 
 

A Brief History of Routes 5 & 20

The migration to central and western New York began shortly after the American Revolution. Other than an Iroquois trail that was little more than a simple foot path, there were no roads west of modern day Utica. Companies that had established a presence in major settlements lobbied for a public road. In 1794, the New York State Legislature passed a law commissioning a public road from Utica to Caledonia in “as straight a line as the topography of the land would allow.” This road was officially known as the "Great Genesee Road.” Four years later, the legislature called for an expansion to Buffalo.

By 1805, most sections of The Great Genesee Road were privately maintained toll roads. The Seneca Turnpike ran from Utica to Canandaigua and the Ontario and Geneseo Turnpike from Genesee Road to Buffalo. However, due to a loss of revenue to the Erie Canal, by mid century most turnpike companies had dissolved and the roads reverted to public control.

New York began paving main routes in the early 1900s to accommodate the increasing numbers of automobiles. Newly formed Auto Trail Associations began marking designated routes, such as the Yellowstone Trail which ran from Seattle, Washington to Plymouth, Massachusetts. This trail incorporated modern US 20 from Pennsylvania to Silver Creek, then mostly modern NY 5 from Silver Creek to Albany, then modern US 20 again from Albany to Massachusetts.

Today, Routes 5 &20 offers scenic vistas, charming small towns, historic homes and unique businesses - it’s a great way to experience local character.

Home